Desktop Controllers: Shortcut Keys or Dials?
Start with the Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 when you want dedicated shortcut keys; consider Stream Deck + when turning dials is central to your work. Verify support for your actual apps before buying either.
A desktop controller earns its space by removing repeated steps from work you already do. It is less useful when you are buying hardware before identifying the tasks it should control. Our shortlist covers two Elgato layouts, not every macro pad or editing console. Begin with five actions you repeat each day and decide whether each needs a button press or a continuous adjustment.
Which desktop shortcut controllers should you consider?
These are starting recommendations by use case, not a ranking of the entire market. Check the reason and the reason to skip before choosing.
Repeated commands on dedicated keys
Elgato Stream Deck MK.2
Why consider it: The 15-key layout is a good starting point for discrete actions such as app shortcuts and scene changes. Confirm support for the exact apps you use.
The tradeoff: It has no rotary dials. A shortcut pad is unnecessary if existing keyboard shortcuts already solve the task.
Skip this if physical dials are the main feature you need.
Manufacturer details for Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 ↗Supported adjustments using dials
Elgato Stream Deck +
Why consider it: Its rotary controls and touch strip are the reason to choose it when you want physical adjustments alongside shortcut keys.
The tradeoff: It has fewer keys than the MK.2. Dial support depends on your software and the actions you configure.
Skip this if you mainly want the larger physical key count of the MK.2.
Manufacturer details for Elgato Stream Deck + ↗How to choose desktop shortcut controllers
Keys suit distinct actions; dials suit adjustments
The MK.2 provides 15 LCD keys. Stream Deck + combines eight keys with dials and a touch strip. Opening a workspace and triggering a command are button-like tasks; adjusting a supported parameter can benefit from a dial. More control types are not automatically better. Choose the layout that maps to your recurring actions without forcing a new routine.
Software support comes before hardware appeal
Check the manufacturer’s current operating-system requirements, the integration for your application and whether the action you need is supported. A product image showing an app logo does not tell you that every function in that app is available. If an integration requires an additional subscription or purchase, include that in your decision before comparing controller prices.
Start with one useful profile
Plan a simple layout you can remember: your core apps, a few frequent commands and clear labels. Add complexity only when it saves effort. Leave room on the desk for the controller without pushing the keyboard or mouse into an awkward position. If keyboard shortcuts already solve the task comfortably, there may be no reason to buy extra hardware.
Before you buy
- List five repeated actions and mark each as a press or an adjustment.
- Verify your operating system and exact app integration.
- Check any extra software cost and the required connection.
- Plan a desk position and a first profile before selecting a larger controller.
Live prices, stock and price history are not checked here. If you already have an offer, check your offer on WinBlackFriday; its result depends on the information you enter.
Questions about desktop shortcut controllers
Do I need to stream to use a Stream Deck?
No. The buying question is whether supported shortcuts and integrations serve your work. A non-streamer with repeated app actions may find a use for it; someone without those tasks may not.
Does Stream Deck + have more shortcut keys?
No. It has eight keys, while the MK.2 has 15. The reason to compare the Plus is its dials and touch strip, not a higher physical key count.
Will every dial work in every editing app?
Do not assume that. Confirm the particular app, integration and parameter you want to control. Our guided recommendation distinguishes layouts; it does not certify compatibility with every software version or plug-in.